King of Beasts: Comfort and Squats

1 Ram Interior II

Photography by Evan Sears

When you put 1,600 miles on a pair of full-size behemoth pickup trucks with monster gooseneck trailers locked down in the beds, you get very familiar with their interiors and which one offers the best features and creature comforts that fit your towing style — and your body. So here's what we thought of the 2013 Ram 3500 Heavy Duty and 2013 Ford F-450 crew cabs.

One of our biggest pet peeves is not having a way to see what's happening inside the engine or transmission. We like that Ford's Super Duty lineup allows drivers to see what the transmission is doing with big numbers in the gauge cluster. Although you can actually get the Aisin Ram HD to show you what gears you're moving through by making it think you want to lock out a top gear, the readouts are so small they're almost unusable.

Despite that, we were very impressed with the amount of engine and truck data available on the Ram's information screen. We most often kept an eye on the turbo and exhaust brake screens that let us know how hard the two systems were working during our uphill climbs and rapid descents. No other heavy-duty truck has that. That said, Ford's Super Duty gauge cluster and font choices are very easy to read, and all the information we need is where we expect it to be. If you like mountains of data at your fingertips and don't mind scrolling for a bit to see your temperatures and pressures, the Ram is probably your choice. For us, we'll do just fine with Ford's clean, simple approach.

We liked that Ford's mirrors were able to electronically extend a few inches (and fold flat to the doors), but we didn't like how small they were. The Ram mirrors, although only manually foldable and collapsable and one inch narrower than the Ford's in width, it did have almost four inches of extra reach. Oddly, the Ford's ugly "snap-on" dualie fender flares made it a little easier to see around the rear body to the trailer's outer tires. The Ram's more stylish molded rear fenders made it almost impossible to see around or behind them, making the trailer more difficult to see.

The Ram's overall ride quality was hands down better than Ford's ride in both empty and fully loaded scenarios. The Ram's rear suspension felt solid, quiet and strong enough to pull and move our big load without sacrificing any rear ride quality. Additionally, we liked the Ram's seats and assume that they probably had a lot to do with our feeling less fatigued after a full day of driving with a loaded trailer. The Ford's suspension felt a little more rigid and less capable of dealing with road irregularities, especially when empty, and we had some bad leaf spring squeaking throughout our test when maneuvering into and out of tight spaces like gas stations or hotel parking lots.

1 Ford Interior II

Both cabins were quiet, but the Super Duty was just a touch ahead, most likely because the V-8 Power Stroke is one of the quietest big diesels on the market, and the Cummins, well, it isn't.

Overall, the quality and execution of the Ram Laramie Longhorn interior is impressive. Soft-touch leather is everywhere, and all the materials under your elbows, arms, hands and fingers have solidity, cushioning and grip. Our only complaint with the Ram has to do with the thickness of the steering wheel. Does it have to be as thick as a baseball bat? We found that holding onto the wheel for extended periods was tiring and at times, a little clumsy. Likewise, the Platinum Super Duty offers a nice interior but doesn't really distinguish itself enough from a comparably equipped $50,000 pickup. If these trucks are going to cost nearly $70,000, they ought to look like it. The Ford does not; the Ram does.

Squat Tests

Our final test measured how well the rear suspensions, rated to be the strongest in their respective lineups, handle a fifth-wheel hitch. Specifically, how much squat does it put to the rear axle when it has to handle several thousand pounds?

As it turned out, both trucks experienced just less than 2 inches of squat when loaded with our gooseneck trailers. We should note there was about a 2-inch difference in the height of the trucks' bed floors, which was also about the same difference between the two bed-rail heights. As a result, to keep the trailer properly level, we had to extend the gooseneck coupler on the Ford's trailer to accommodate the lower bed height.

1 Ford Squat II

Overview | Acceleration | Braking | Fuel Economy | Comfort and Squats | Results

Comments

Interesting, I like the Ram interior and exterior the best, although I actually perfer the giant rear wheel flares on the Ford compared to the whole fender treatment that the Ram gets.

it would be nice to know just what the goose-neck load was- was each trailer loaded to for maximum allowable hitch weight?

God the Ford looks so ugly, I'd have no comfort if I had to look at that ugly thing every night if it sat in my drive way!

Ram interior is gaudy. The Platinum looks better with less.

GUTS
GLORY
BEST INTERIOR ON THE MARKET
MAKES THE FORD LOOK DIME STORE CHEAP
RAM

if you like gaudy leather, fat steering wheels, 90's style white guages and check engine lights.

It'll be interesting to see how the ride quality on the '14 Ram 3500 with it's factory air suspension vs the '13 Ram 3500! It' got to be a lot nicer ride.

I have to say the Laramie Longhorn interior is a little gaudy, but the Fords looks like a normal truck, not to mention how ugly the center console is.... although it is better looking than the GM twins center console, the GM's is hands down the ugliest interior..... well I actually think that the Fords and GM's tie in being ugly. I'll take a normal Laramie Ram 3500......

I'm not a fan of the "cowboy" interior look but the Ram interior does look more luxurious than the Ford's cabin. I do think that those Ford flares are ugly.
I'd rather have a simpler to read instrument cluster like the Ford. I had a chance to sit in a 2013 F350 Platinum and it is nice. Much nicer than the interior of the 2014 GMC I sat in. The Denali trim better be great because the Platinum interior kills the LTZ.

Is a squat test really relevant in this class of truck?

well both trucks are impressive in power and comfort both had some shortcomings but the ram has the ford beat hands down with the info and they make after market mirrors to fix visibiliy my vote is to the ram



Post a Comment

Please remember a few rules before posting comments:

  • Try to be civil to your fellow blog readers.
  • Stay on topic. We want to hear your opinions and thoughts, but please only comment about the specified topic in the blog post.

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In